A következő címkéjű bejegyzések mutatása: Law. Összes bejegyzés megjelenítése
A következő címkéjű bejegyzések mutatása: Law. Összes bejegyzés megjelenítése

2014. április 2., szerda

The Fidesz had been curing – It could have been prevent the lot of penalty

Really it should have been only this, and then the Hungarian tax-payers shouldn’t have to pay the penalty damages because of the case transferences? It’s a public joke.



We can start this story from far away, but there is no sense for the enumeration. They will do this a few years later on the law schools, when probably the purpose which allusive the special criminal cases and which is supported by the 2/3 government will be a curriculum in there.


This made it happen that Tünde Handó, who was newly elected president of the National Judicial Office in the January of 2012, could appoint court which are equal in scope but it’s diverge than the general cognizance courts in politically tender cases, like the Sukoró’s plot change, the BKV case, or the trial of György Hunvald. The National Judiciary Office had the same charge from lot of sides, that they appoint these kinds of cases according a sin which countryside court has a stricter or more extenuate judgment, according to the earlier cases.

Let’s go to Kecskemét

The BKV case should had been trial in the Budapest Court, but Tünde Handó appointed it to the Kecskemét Court in the February of 2012, with the allude to the workloads of the other court. Against the decision the concerned people couldn’t make an appeal but they made a constitutional complaint and they asked for suspend of the process. All of this didn’t block the process, the appointed judge started the case in the Kecskemét Court. She questioned all the defendants and almost all of the witnesses. Roughly after 50 days of hearings December of 2013 came, when the Constitutional Court in their decision established that the laws about the case transferences were repealed by the Parliament and it’s come up against the Basic Law and against the international rules. 


2013. május 15., szerda

The European Court of Human Rights Declares Hungary Guilty!

Hagyó Wins in Strasbourg! Just this morning the Second Section of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) in Strasbourg, France delivered its decision on the case Hagyó vs Hungary. The court announced that it found the Hungarian judiciary guilty and thus in violation of all alleged charges. The official decision is here.



Hagyó, former Deputy Mayor of Budapest and Member of Parliament, lodged a complaint with the ECHR on September 6, 2010 regarding the circumstances of his pretrial detention.

European Court of Human Rights Ready to Announce Verdict about the Hagyó Case

According to Népszava, a Hungarian daily, the European Court of Human Rights announced that it will make a verdict on Tuesday, April 23 regarding the trial of former Budapest Deputy Mayor Miklós Hagyó.




Hagyó and his lawyer turned to the court in Strasbourg in 2010. Citing that investigators denied his basic rights established in the European Convention on Human Rights, the former MSZP leader claimed that Hungarian investigators specifically violated Article 3, Article 5, and Article 8. The petition is viewable on HagyoMiklos.com

HagyoMiklos.com Offers Documentary Facts


Miklós Hagyó’s digital presence has been expanding, which is great news considering it has come in the form of a few blogs and a website offering case-related documents.


 The website, hagyomiklos.com, has published information concerning much of his legal plight such as trial testimonies from Hagyó and other defendants.

While the Judiciary is Gagged, the Public is Blind

Even while under major scrutiny from the European Parliament and the U.S. Helsinki Commission for shady backroom politics, Hungary still persists on operating behind closed doors.


Just last week I wrote that the Constitutional Court had summoned President of the National Judicial Office (PNJO) Tünde Handó to provide a testimony in connection with her decisions to transfer certain trials from one tribunal to another. This is considered an alarming capability since courts usually represent a specific place on the political spectrum. 

The European Union Fights Back

Regarding a controversial piece of legislation passed by the Fidesz supermajority which hastily forced into early retirement 750 judges, in a time when retirement ages are increasing internationally due to economic forces, the European Commission and the European Parliament has decided to pursue a more proactive approach in dealing with Prime Minister Orbán and his Fidesz cronies.



 Prime Minister Orbán on the Defense

Source: http://www.bbj.hu/politics/ec-ready-to-check-hungarys-compliance-with-ruling-of-the-european-court-of-justice_65350

The Constitutional Court Levels the Playing Field: Tünde Handó Ordered to Testify on Hagyó Case


According to a recent article in Népszava, a Hungarian daily newspaper, the Hungarian Constitutional Court has ordered President of the National Judicial Office Tünde Handó to appear before the court on April 23rd. 





The Court is demanding a testimony from Handó about the questionable transfer of the Hagyó Case from the Budapest court system to the Kecskemét Tribunal.


2013. május 14., kedd

The Court of Budapest would send the Hagyó-case to another court


The Court of Budapest ask for to the transference of the Miklós Hagyó and his partner's case, and an other seeded case.

On Tuesday, the president of the Court of Budapest proposed at the president of the National Judicial Office(OBH) to transfer two high priority case- informed the Court of Budapest. That Tünde Handó is the president of the OBH, who is József Szájer fidesz-party politician's wife, the family friend of Viktor Orbán head of government, and whose nomination was attecked many times. 


(Photo source: nol.hu)

The announcement not tells, but according to the communicated details from one of these cases, one proceeding is Miklós Hagy formes socialistoc deputy lord mayor and his partner's case. How they wrote in their announcement, the president asked that, to appoint another court what has similar competence with the Court of Budapest, for Norbert W and his 27 others commited with especially significant financial detriment caused authorial or coherence with infrigement of literary property felony and other felonies, or rather Miklós H and his 14 others commited in a criminal organization, misappropriation which caused an especially huge financial detriment and becaouse of other felonies trial.

2013. április 7., vasárnap

Testimonies from an Olympian, a Film Director: Beacons of Light?

The trial of the 15 associates of the Budapest Transit Company (BKV) heard the testimonies from two star witnesses on March 21, 2013.

The hearing in the Kecskemét Tribunal received Gábor Csapó, a former Hungarian water polo Olympic champion, and Zoltán Kamondi, a well-known film director.





Csapó, once a star defenseman on the 1976 and 1980 Olympic teams, allegedly sought financial support from BKV for his water polo school. It seems however that certain municipal regulations restricted BKV from providing sponsorship in this situation. The prosecution asserts that Csapó and primary defendant Miklós Hagyó have a close relationship, so when Hagyó was Budapest Deputy Mayor between 2006 and 2010 the two men arranged an agreement. Csapó’s company, Csapó Ltd., would receive funding from BKV in exchange for advertising BKV’s logo at the school and on the school’s promotional material. The 2008 contract valued at 2.85 million HUF ($12,551.08 at the time of writing) was “unnecessary,” claims the prosecution.

2013. április 2., kedd

Fair and Balanced? Not in Hungary, ‘Scoreboard’ Says



The European Union’s executive body, the European Commission (EC), recently published a report on the different judicial systems within the EU. The report, titled The EU Justice Scoreboard, was created with the objective to “assist the EU and the Member States to achieve more effective justice by providing objective, reliable and comparable data on the functioning of the justice systems of all Member States.”





Of the 29 Member States included in the report, Hungary fared well in timely decisions. That was about the only good news for the Central European country, though.

2013. március 28., csütörtök

The 4th Amendment (Un)officially Strips Hungary of Democracy

“We are people too!” People protest the 4th amendment outside of Parliament in Budapest on March 11, 2013.

Hungary has again made international headlines. As in the recent past, it is because of the political antics of Prime Minister Viktor Orbán and his Fidesz cronies, who wield a super-majority presence in the legislative body, Parliament.






Mainstream international media powerhouses like the Wall Street Journal, the New York Times, Al Jazeera, Spiegel, and BBC all reported on the newest amendment to the 14-month-old constitution.

Former CEO of BKV Is In The Hot Seat

On March 5th, the Kecskemét Tribunal in Hungary saw the continuation of the trial of the Miklós Hagyó and 14 other defendants associated with the Budapest Transit Company (BKV).




The hearing was fairly mundane – not much fresh information was presented.

The most interesting occurrence, though, involved Mr. István Kocsis. He was promoted to CEO of the transit company immediately following Zsolt Balogh’s time in the high seat. Kocsis therefore was responsible for transferring the demanded BKV-related data to the investigation authorities. Included in the submitted material was an internal audit of BKV’s operations. According to Erzsébet Székelyné, the current director of communications at BKV, the audit ordered by Kocsis was hastily created. She stated in court during the March 5th hearing that because of the imposed sense of urgency around the audits, they were not “substantial.”

Justice or No Justice: The Prosecution Manipulates the Indictment, Again



Justice or No Justice: The Prosecution Manipulates the Indictment, Again


Justice or No Justice: The Prosecution Manipulates the Indictment, Again
The trial of Miklós Hagyó and 14 other defendants continued in Kecskemét, Hungary on February 28th. During the hearing, the court witnessed another alteration to the indictment. This time, the changes were made to the alleged financial damage accumulated to the Budapest Transit Company (BKV). Unfortunately, the article from which I get this information does not detail the modifications. I would not be surprised if the prosecution and/or the Kecskemét Tribunal obstructs this information from the public.
The prosecution has already changed the charges in the indictment many times. In fact, defendants and followers of the case have dubbed the indictment the “political pamphlet.” This, no doubt, refers to the widely held belief that the case is show trial – a highly publicized trial in which the verdict is rigged. One cannot help but sympathize.
Out of curiosity, I briefly researched the possibility to change the original charges of an indictment in two other judicial systems which are usually considered “fair” and objective.
According to the Department of Justice’s website, it is generally forbidden to alter the original indictment charges in the United States. For example, the 1962 case of Russell v. United States yielded the opinion that if the original charges were changed or amended, then the defendant(s) “could then be convicted on the basis of facts not found by, and perhaps not even presented to, the grand jury which indicted him.”
In England, the Crown Prosecution Service’s website states that amending the indictment requires “an express order of the court to comply with s5(1) of the Indictments Act 1915.” Otherwise, the amendment is null.
Judicial law permits the alteration of original indictment charges in Hungary. I fail to see, though, how that supports a fair trial. If the prosecution can amend or draft new charges throughout the trial, why even bother to create an indictment in the first place?


Source: http://thehagyocase.wordpress.com/

Hagyó, the AAM Contract, and the Holey Accusations from the Prosecution



Hagyó, the AAM Contract, and the Holey Accusations from the Prosecution

Hagyó, the AAM Contract, and the Holey Accusations from the Prosecution
The Budapest Metro Line 4 (Metro4) has for many years been a major project for the Budapest Transit Authority (BKV). Once finished, it will be the first fully automated metro line in Hungary. Totaling more than 12 kilometers (7.5 miles), it will pass from south Buda under the Danube River and continue deep into Pest. The project has been notorious, however, for its continuity. Critics of the project have considered its progress slow and its management incompetent; tell-tale signs of government corruption. Those in charge of the project say that a lack of resources and manpower are the true hindrances.
Miklós Hagyó is quite familiar with the project. From 2006 to 2010 he served as deputy mayor of Budapest, and in that capacity he was responsible for the political oversight of the city’s assets. In the trial of Hagyó and the other 14 associates of BKV, the prosecution claims that Hagyó “instructed” then chief executive of BKV Attila Antal to strike up a business agreement with the Hungarian consulting firm AAM, who has a strong public sector track record. The alleged purpose of the arrangement was the creation of an assessment report on Metro4. It intended to ascertain the quality and progress of the project’s “management, the administration, as well as quality assurance activities.” The prosecutors assert that Hagyó was required to present the report to the City Council’s Budget Committee.
At this point, everything seems fairly normal. As usual with the Hagyó Case, though, the abnormalities appear when one analyzes the prosecution’s accusations and methodology.  Regarding the contract with AAM, the prosecution claims in the indictment on page 17 section 21 the services provided by AAM were “unnecessary,” and they caused BKV financial damages totaling 50,093,400 forints (nearly 230,000.00 USD at the time of writing).
Here arises the first question: By what means has the prosecution determined this contract to be unnecessary? There are most certainly no explanations provided in the original indictment. Neither has the prosecution explained thus far in the trial how this contract and the related work were unnecessary.  Besides that simple question, the major refute to this assertion is that the prosecution admittedly neglected to seek consultation from any organization or individual who could be capable of accurately determining the necessity of the AAM contract.
On the other hand, Miklós Hagyó did provide ample evidence for the worthiness of the contract during his first in-court testimony. Perhaps most significantly, though, Hagyó indicated that while he scoured through tens of thousands of pages of collected evidence related to the AAM contract, he failed to find the actual Metro4 assessment report…Let me repeat that: The prosecution did not provide the assessment report of the Metro4 project in the case file. Mind you, this accusation that Hagyó “instructed” his subordinate to create a needless contract with AAM from which he could extort a significant sum of money was one of the most significant reasons Hagyó was forced to endure nine months of hard jail time prior to the trial. The AAM accusation was one of the biggest indicators that Hagyó was an Al Capone-like figure, dictating his less capable minions to do his dirty deeds. Indeed, this questionably “unnecessary” contract which Hagyó allegedly “instructed” his subordinate to create is a major catalyst for the entire trial.  And the prosecution did not even include the report, the primary evidence, in the case file.
Other parts of Hagyó’s testimony strongly support the necessity of the AAM contract. For example, he included several quotes from then City Council members who reviewed the report produced by AAM. Here are a few excerpts:
“It is a very fair, well-prepared report. It also shows that we got a lot of information.”
– Former Minister of Transport Katona Kálmán
“We can thank both the referring Deputy Mayor [Miklós Hagyó] and László Becker [Metro4 Commissioner] that this material was prepared…”
- Dr. Gábor Dancs
There are more which attested to the necessity and value of the assessment report from AAM.  They are available in this section of Hagyó’s testimony. He also systematically explains how he was not directly involved with the Metro4 project or AAM. According to him, the Metro Commissioner László Becker held the reigns for the project’s development.  Hagyó claimed that he was merely the political representative of the project for the City Council.
Despite, these shortcomings in the validity of the prosecution’s case against Hagyó, the trial persists. When I inquire to those who follow the case how this is possible – how a trial can subsist when an overwhelming amount of evidence supports innocence of the defendants – the Hungarians just shrug their shoulders. “It’s Hungary. It’s normal,” is a typical response.
Please visit http://www.hagyomiklos.com to view the original indictment and the testimony of Miklós Hagyó.

2013. február 28., csütörtök

First, Let’s Pick All the Judges


First, Let’s Pick All the Judges

Another Hungary post from my Princeton colleague Kim Lane Scheppele, after the jump.
First, Let’s Pick all the Judges
Kim Lane Scheppele
March 9, 2012
Europe doesn’t like what is happening to the legal system in Hungary.
These days in Hungary, one person picks all the judges. This judicial “czar” just announced today that she was filling 129 vacant judgeships. Only 23 of the newly assigned judges were already judges before. That means fully 106 of these positions are awarded to judicial newcomers. New judges enter the Hungarian legal system for three-year probationary terms, under the watchful eye of the very government that will decide on their reappointments. These judges, therefore, are independent at their peril, knowing that their jobs depend on how the government evaluates what they do.
The judicial czar also has the power to assign specific cases to specific courts. Hungarian law specifies where cases are normally tried, but in Hungary’s new constitutional order, these usual rules can be overridden by the judicial czar who can transfer specific cases to courts other than the ones that are assigned by law. These transfers of cases do not have to be accompanied by reasons explaining why the judicial czar selected those cases or why they wound up in the courts that they did.
What is to prevent Hungary’s judicial czar from picking the judges and then moving sensitive cases to the judges the government prefers? Not the law, at least not anymore.
To Europe, these practices look like the political control of the judiciary. The rapid acceleration of European actions about the judiciary in recent weeks is a signal that Hungary has hit a European nerve.
On Thursday, March 8, the European Commission sent a “reasoned opinion” to Budapest asking the Hungarian government for more information about Hungary’s radical judicial reform. The Commission has given Hungary only one month to respond, an unusually short turnaround time.
On another front, the European Commission for Democracy through Law (an expert body otherwise known as the Venice Commission) will conclude next week that the changes to the judiciary, particularly the concentrations of powers in the hands of one official, “contradict European standards.” The report will say that the constitution must be amended to ensure an independent judiciary. It is a hard hitting report, as we learned when the Népszabadság, Hungary’s largest daily newspaper, leaked news of the draftthis week.
A few weeks ago, the European Parliament started a process that may culminate in Hungary losing its vote within the European Union. To decide whether to proceed further, the Parliament wanted to hear Venice Commission’s expert view of the judicial reforms, which we have just learned is scathing. More assessments on other aspects of Hungary’s constitutional changes are to come.
Hungary is not waiting for European permission to put its new judicial plan into action. The Fidesz government is moving quickly to consolidate its constitutional revolution. Soon, the new system will be so entrenched that it will be very difficult for Europe (or for that matter, a future Hungarian government) to change it. The first batch of new judgeships appointed under the new system was announced today. The migration of court cases in Hungary started a couple of weeks ago.
On February 17, Tünde Handó, president of the newly created National Judicial Office of Hungary – the new judicial czar – transferred the first set of cases from the crowded Metropolitan Court of Budapest to various less-crowded courts in the countryside. According to the Fidesz government, moving cases around the legal system like this improves the efficiency of the judicial process by giving judges with smaller dockets the opportunity help out their busier colleagues.
In Hungary, as elsewhere, justice often moves too slowly. A reform that speeds up the processing of cases is understandable and even laudable. But in Hungary, unlike elsewhere, these judicial reforms cap the political program that has put the independence of the judiciary in question.
Three of the nine cases that were just moved out of the capital to the countryside are politically sensitive. One happens to be the highest profile corruption case involving the main opposition party, the Socialists. Former Budapest Deputy Mayor Miklós Hagyó and 14 others are charged with embezzling about $70 million from the Budapest Transportation Authority and the Fidesz government is seeking a 20-year prison term for Hagyó. His case was transferred to Kecskemét. The choice of Kecskemét has raised some eyebrows, since the president of the county court there (who will assign the case to a specific judge) was one of the few court leaders in the country who did not sign a petition to the government protesting its judicial reforms.
Another case involves former Fidesz economic advisor Tamás Varga, who has been serving a jail term after being convicted of embezzling about $140 million in government funds. His appeal against his conviction has been transferred to Debrecen.
Still another case against SCD Balaton Holding, apparently involving alleged real estate speculation, has generated substantial interest among members of the far-right Jobbik party. It was transferred to Kaposvár.
Why should anyone be concerned about a few cases moving to less crowded courts? Because the judicial czar has close ties to the government and there are few legal constraints on her actions. When one-third of the cases moved in the first round are of serious political interest, then we might well wonder what’s going on.
This reassignment of cases is occurring in a context in which roughly one-tenth of all of the judgeships in the country are suddenly available to be filled with new judges.
In June 2011, a new law suspended all new judicial appointments until the new constitution came into effect on January 1, 2012. During that six-month period, judicial vacancies mounted, waiting for a new system of appointments to begin. Then-Supreme-Court-President András Baka spoke out stronglyagainst the attacks on an independent judiciary, not least because he, as the president of the Supreme Court, was also president of the Judicial Council that had the responsibility for selecting judges.
In the end, President Baka lost his job. When the new constitution took effect on January 1, Baka was singled out for removal in the “transitional provisions” to the new constitution. In Baka’s place, the Fidesz Parliament elected Péter Darák, a little-known Supreme Court justice and academic tax specialist who had become a judge on the Supreme Court in 2000 during the first Fidesz government.
The Supreme Court presidency and six months of frozen judgeships created a number of judicial openings for the Fidesz government to fill. But those were not the only open seats on the bench. The new constitution suddenly lowered the retirement age for judges so that, instead of being able to retire at 70, judges were forced to retire at 62, effective immediately. Through this measure, the government received another windfall of judgeships to name.
In an interview on January 31 in his Budapest office, Róbert Répassy, secretary of state for justice, told me that 236 judges would be immediately affected by forced early retirement measure alone. Of that number, he said, the great majority were judges who were already collecting pensions and working only part time. But he also explained that a number of senior judges holding important posts would also be required to retire. Eight out of the 20 county court presidents, two of the five appeals court presidents, and 20 of the 80 justices on the Supreme Court would have to leave office in 2012 because of the new retirement age, allowing the current government to replace them, too.
And how are several hundred new judges to be selected? Under the old constitutional order, judges themselves ran the process of judicial appointment so that it was hard for the government of the day to control who was named to the bench. Under the new constitutional order, all of the new judges are selected by one person, elected for a term of nine years by Fidesz’s reliable two-thirds majority in the Parliament. That person is Tünde Handó.
Tünde Handó occupies a newly created post in a newly created agency: president of the National Judicial Office (NJO). She has been given the power to fill any judicial vacancy that arises – in both civilian and military courts.
Handó’s selection for this sensitive post raised eyebrows both in Hungary and around the world. Before becoming judicial czar, Handó was a long-serving labor court judge, and also a long-time close friend of Prime Minister Viktor Orbán and his wife. She is married to József Szájer, a Fidesz founder and a current Member of the European Parliament who claims to have written the new Hungarian constitution on his iPad. To avoid conflict of interest, Szájerresigned his Fidesz party posts after Handó’s election as head of the NJO. But he still holds his Fidesz seat in the European Parliament. Handó’s intimate ties with the Fidesz inner circle have not endeared her to the democratic opposition which claims that she cannot be neutral.
Handó has not been in the job long, so it is too early to judge just how she will handle her new responsibilities. Let’s assume that she will exercise these powers with exemplary professionalism.
Even with an angel in this job, however, the powers of the president of the National Judicial Office are unprecedented in European practice for their sweeping range as well as for the inability of the affected actors to appeal or contest her decisions. In this job, Handó can hire and fire judges, evaluate them, reassign them to new jobs, and assign them cases to decide. And for most of these decisions, her word is both first and last in the process.
Take judicial selection. While technically, Handó must pick new judges from among lists of those selected by judicial councils in the various courts, she is the one who controls the timing and terms of the judicial “tenders” through which interested candidates apply for the jobs. If a judicial council does not give her a choice she likes from among the applicants at that court, she can refuse to appoint any of the recommended judges and start the process over by announcing a new tender, until the judicial council for the court in question sends her a candidate she is willing to name as a judge. She doesn’t have an absolutely free hand in this process, but she controls most of the relevant aspects of the search. Among other things, she can attend all of the meetings of the judicial councils that will ultimately make their recommendations to her.
When she decides to bring a new judge into the system, Handó must recommend the appointment to the President of the Republic who then formally names the judge. (The current President, also elected by the Fidesz parliamentary supermajority, has not refused anything he has been asked to do by the current government.) Judges who are already on the bench can be moved around with Handó’s say-so alone, including promotions, demotions and assignments elsewhere in the country. She may also appoint and relieve from duty all of the court leaders, who assign cases to specific judges and otherwise manage their courts. There is no procedure for judges to contest her decisions unless a judge has been asked to resign.
Handó’s job also extends to the evaluation of judges, since the law requires that they provide annual data directly to her. The law on the judiciary does not specify what information judges must produce for these evaluations; that will come later in rules that she has the power to issue. She, along with the new president of the Supreme Court, may also investigate judges through an only vaguely defined procedure that may lead to a judge’s removal. Among other things, the law does not specify what standards judges would have to violate to put themselves under risk of investigation and potential removal. She may also “suggest” that disciplinary proceedings be initiated against specific judges within their courts.
Handó also has the power to grant exemptions to judges if they would otherwise have to leave their posts, for example when they hit the mandatory retirement age. In response to the infringement procedure that the European Commission has launched against Hungary for age discrimination against judges, the government is now considering a proposal that will enable judges who have reached the new retirement age to petition to be kept on a big longer, as Secretary Répassy told me. And who will decide whether a judge can keep his or her job past the new retirement age? Handó! Secretary Répassy, however, knew of no procedure under consideration for these decisions to be contested if Handó rules against the judges who want to stay on.
As president of the NJO, Handó may also initiate legislation regarding the judiciary, propose to Parliament the budget for the judiciary and determine (it seems, by herself) the number of judgeships that should exist in Hungary in the first place. She is also given the power to speed up for special treatment cases that have social importance. But how she is to determine social importance is not defined by law.
And this brings us back full circle to the cases that Handó moved out of Budapest to regional courts a few weeks ago. Yes, she has the power to do that too – and it is (according to the government) a power that is now enshrined not just in the law, but in the new constitution itself.
Handó’s powers to assign specific cases to any court in the country came into the constitution by a circuitous route. Seeking to control where individual cases were decided, the government inserted parallel provisions into the new law on office of the public prosecutor and the new law on the judiciary, provisions that allowed both the chief public prosecutor and the president of the NJO to choose the courts that would hear particular cases. But the Hungarian Constitutional Court, in a December decision, found that it was unconstitutional for the public prosecutor to have this power because it violated principles of judicial independence. Had the Constitutional Court been able to review the law on the judiciary (and with it, the provision that allowed the president of the NJO to select the courts to hear specific cases), the Court probably would have found that provision unconstitutional too.
Was this a strong Constitutional Court standing up to the government? By surface appearances, yes. By practical consequences, no. In fact, the Constitutional Court’s decision was quickly and easily overridden.
In response to the decision, the government simply slipped this language – language giving both the public prosecutor and the president of the NJO the power to assign specific cases to any court in the country – into the “transitional provisions on the constitution.” This was a giant bill held open for collecting random constitutional changes until the very last minute before the constitution went into effect. The Parliament passed these transitional provisions on December 30. According to the government, the transitional provisions qualify as constitutional amendments, even though many of the provisions are not in fact transitional but make permanent changes to the constitution and even though the transitional provisions were not passed according to the parliamentary procedures for a constitutional amendment.
The status of these provisions as constitutional amendments is presently being challenged by Hungarian constitutional lawyer Gábor Halmai in a petition sent to the Parliamentary Commissioner for Human Rights who has the power, if he chooses, to forward the petition to the Constitutional Court for review. (People used to be able to petition the Constitutional Court directly in cases like this but, under the new constitution, they must now go through the filter of the ombudsman.) Though the Commissioner has had the petition for more than a month, however, he has not yet indicated what he will do. Even if the Commissioner forwards the petition to the Constitutional Court, the Fidesz government has already packed the Court. The government has been able to appoint seven of the current 15 judges of that Court in less than two years, adding to the several judges sympathetic to Fidesz who were on the Court already. Few now expect the Court to challenge the government in any serious way even if it receives this petition.
In the meantime, however, it is through this alleged constitutional amendment that Tünde Handó now has the power to take cases out of the Budapest courts and move them anywhere else in the country she pleases.
Judicial independence requires that judges are free of political influence. But under the new constitutional order, where the power to hire, investigate, promote and remove judges is in the hands of the same person who then also makes specific case assignments to courts, Hungary no longer can guarantee that judges will remain independent. It will take strong judges not to be swayed when the state official who gives them specific cases to decide also holds their careers in her hands.
No wonder Europe is worried about judicial independence in Hungary.
The three laws I discuss in this post are:
This post was inspired by an Amicus Brief to the Venice Commission, coordinated by Professor Gábor Halmai of the University of Budapest (ELTE), on which I also worked. The Venice Commission will be presenting its report on the laws on the judiciary discussed here for adoption in its plenary session on March 16-17 .
A personal note: I would like to thanks many readers of this blog for supportive personal messages and for the huge turnouts for my lectures when I was in Budapest. You can see my lecture at Central European University in full here.


Hungary’s rush toward autocracy


Hungary’s rush toward autocracy

By Editorial Board,January 09, 2012

WHILE THE European Union has been focused on the debt problems of Greece and Italy, a potentially more profound challenge has been developing in the Central European nation of Hungary, a former part of the Soviet bloc that now belongs to NATO and the European Union. Hungary, which still uses its own currency, the forint, is flirting with insolvency. Its 10-year bonds have been fetching interest rates near 10 percent, far above sustainable levels.
But Hungary has another problem too: Its right-wing nationalist government has launched an assault on its democratic system of government. Using a two-thirds majority in parliament, it has pushed through a new constitution as well as a series of fundamental laws that give the ruling party sweeping powers over the judiciary, the media, churches and the central bank. With the new charter and laws taking effect Jan. 1, the government of Prime Minister Viktor Orban now more resembles the autocratic regimes of Russia and Belarus than fellow E.U. democracies.
Some 270 judges are being forced to retire, and sole authority to name their replacements has been given to a close associate of Mr. Orban — who also may choose the courts where cases are assigned. All but 14 religious denominations have been denied official recognition; those losing tax-exempt status and state school payments include the Episcopal and Methodist churches, several Jewish congregations, and all Muslim sects. A leading opposition radio station was denied a license by a new media board controlled by Mr. Orban’s followers. Electoral districts have been redrawn in such a way that the ruling Fidesz party — which lost two of the last three elections — would have won all three.
Mr. Orban has ignored mounting criticism of these initiatives by European and Western governments, including the Obama administration. Instead, he pushed through many more laws during the last weeks of December, including one that strips the central bank of independence and another that fixes flat tax rates in a way that will make it hard for future governments to alter them. This has given leverage to the European commission, because E.U. treaties require central bank independence. With the Hungarian government in desperate need of financing, Brussels and the International Monetary Fund have made clear no help will be forthcoming unless the laws are changed.
At first defiant, Mr. Orban has now dispatched a negotiator to meet with the IMF in Washington; over the weekend he hinted that he might retreat on the central bank. But the European Union, which is due to consider Hungary’s case this week, should not limit itself to the financial sphere in pushing back against Mr. Orban’s concentration of power. The new laws governing the judiciary, religious bodies and the media are incompatible with basic human rights and democratic checks and balances. For the European Union to tolerate them in a member state would be a breach of the community’s essential character.

2013. február 6., szerda

Does Hagyó stays in Kecskemét unconstitutionally?


Does Hagyó stays in Kecskemét unconstitutionally?
Bárándy Péter lawyer, who is the former Minister of Justice, proposed the transference of the BKV case to Budapest on the Thursday’s hearing on the Kecskemét Court. Hadnagy Ibolya judge rejected the proposal. In the proposal of Bárándy (what he made of the defense of H. Éva defendant) he refers that the Constitutional Court in December as an ex post facto /retroactively exterminated the temporary provisions of the basic law. Since Handó Tünde (who is the wife of Szájer József, Fidesz party) relocated the Hagyó case to the Kecskemét Court (which court already proved their political partiality in the Zuschlag case) by the right of the 11th item of the temporary provisions, in this way according to the proposal’s justification/reasoning they didn’t ensure the right for a legal judge and for basic human rights. For the proposal of the former Minister of Justice all the other defendants and their lawyers joined.

                                   Handó-Tünde.jpg
   (Source: pecsma.hu)

The prosecution on the hearing asked the court for the rejection of the proposal. According to the statement of the accusation the decision/order of the National Judicial Office is operative, because noone checked the constitution of this law. The judge agreed with the reasoning for the rejection from the prosecution. Hadnagy Ibolya reminded that the Constitutional Court only checked this item of the temporary provisions formally, and the transfer didn’t happen based on the basic law, although it happened in accordance with it. According to the standpoint of the lawyers the National Judicial Court’s resolution/decision is paradox with the basic law. Against the rejection Hagyó Miklós and the most of the defendants announced an appeal.  After this the hearing continued with the hearing of H. Éva.

Source: http://www.nepszava.hu/articles/article.php?id=614785

Original:
Alkotmányellenesen marad Kecskeméten Hagyó?
A BKV-per Budapestre történő áthelyezését kezdeményezte a csütörtöki tárgyaláson Bárándy Péter védő, egykori igazságügyi miniszter a Kecskeméti Törvényszéken. Az indítványt Hadnagy Ibolya bírónő elutasította. Bárándy indítványában, amelyet H. Éva vádlott védelmét ellátva tett, arra hivatkozik, hogy az Alkotmánybíróság (AB) december végén visszamenőleges hatállyal megsemmisítette az alaptörvény átmeneti rendelkezéseit. Mivel az átmeneti rendelkezések 11. cikke alapján a fideszes Szájer József felesége, Handó Tünde helyezte a Hagyó-pert a korábban már politikai elfogultságát a Zuschlag-ügyben bizonyító Kecskeméti Törvényszékre, így az indítvány indoklása szerint nem biztosított a törvényes bírához való, alapvető emberi jog. A volt igazságügyi miniszter indítványához minden vádlott és védőik is csatlakoztak.

                                             Handó-Tünde.jpg
(Forrás: pecsma.hu)

Az ügyészség a tárgyaláson az indítvány elutasítását kérte a bíróságtól. A vádhatóság álláspontja szerint az Országos Bírósági Hivatal (OBH) határozata hatályos, ennek a törvénynek az alkotmányosságát ugyanis még senki sem vizsgálta. A bírónő az elutasítás indoklásánál egyetértett az ügyészséggel. Hadnagy Ibolya emlékeztetett rá, hogy az AB csak formai szempontból vizsgálta az átmeneti rendelkezések ezen cikkét, ám az áttétel nem az Alaptörvény alapján, bár azzal összhangban történt. A védők álláspontja szerint azonban az OBH-határozat ellentétes az Alaptörvénnyel. Az elutasítás ellen Hagyó Miklós és a vádlottak többsége fellebbezést jelentett be. Ezt követően H. Éva vádlott meghallgatásával folytatódott a tárgyalás.

2013. január 15., kedd

Hagyó’s complaint is still in Strasbourg – The Népszava’s article from the 14th of December


Hagyó’s complaint is still in Strasbourg – The Népszava’s article from the 14th of December
The court of Strasbourg and the Constitutional Court took in/admit the complaint from the defendants of the BKV case – turned out from the documents which made public on the hagyomiklos.com.
The lawyers of the defendant’s turned to the European Court of Human Rights and to the „rope syndicate” because the president of the National Judicial Office, Handó Tünde transferred the case from the Budapest Court to the Kecskemét Court. According to the petition from the lawyers, basic constitutional rights damaged with the transference of the case.
According to the lawyer of the main defendant (Hagyó Miklós, former deputy lord mayor), Kádár András and his defender fellows the right of the legal judge damaged because the transference was made without the excludability of the detachment, transparency and peremptory.

(Source: kis-kunsag.hu)
According to their standpoint, the damage of the impartiality requirement exist too, because the case was relocated by the National Judicial Office’s president, Handó Tünde (who is the wife of Szájer József, the representation of EP, Fidesz party) to a court where in a similar political connection they already made a serious adjudication in the case of Zuschlag. Moreover the right for the remedy is damaged too, because against the decision (to transfer the case to another court) of the president of the National Judicial Office there was no effective remedy – consist in the petition. For that matter the lawyers already asked for the suspend of the case because of this, but their proposal was rejected by the court and by the Szeged Court (court in second instance).
Original:
Címkék: bkv per hagyó miklós handó tünde kecskemét | Szerző: Hagyó Dosszié | 9:19 am
Befogadta a BKV-büntetőper vádlottjainak panaszát a strasbourgi bíróság és az Alkotmánybíróság (Ab) is - derült ki a hagyomiklos.com-on nyilvánosságra hozott dokumentumokból.
A vádlottak védői azért fordultak az Emberi Jogok Európai Bíróságához, és a taláros testülethez, mert az Országos Bírósági Hivatal (OBH) elnöke, Handó Tünde a per tárgyalására a főváros helyett a Kecskeméti Törvényszéket jelölte ki. A védők beadványa szerint alkotmányos alapjogok sérültek az ügy áthelyezésekor.
A fő vádlott Hagyó Miklós volt főpolgármester-helyettes ügyvédje, Kádár András és védőtársai szerint sérült a törvényes bírához való jog, mivel az áthelyezés az objektivitás, átláthatóság és önkényesség kizárhatósága nélkül történt meg.

 (Forrás: kis-kunsag.hu)

Álláspontjuk szerint fennáll a pártatlanság követelményének sérelme is, hiszen a tárgyalást az OBH elnöke, a fideszes Szájer József felesége szignálta át egy olyan törvényszékre, amely korábban hasonló politikai összefüggésben már súlyos ítéletet hozott a Zuschlag-ügyben. Valamint sérült a jogorvoslathoz való jog is, mivel az OBH elnökének más bíróságot kijelölő döntése ellen a jogszabályok nem biztosítottak hatékony jogorvoslatot - áll a beadványban. A védők egyébként mindezek alapján már korábban kérték a büntetőper felfüggesztését, de indítványukat a bíróság, majd az ítélőtábla is elutasította.
NÉPSZAVA-információ /

The European Court of Human Rights Remains Silent





The European Court of Human Rights Remains Silent


According to a December 14th, 2012 post from the Hungarian blog Hagyó Dosszié, a complaint filed to the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) and the Hungarian Constitutional Court from the defendants in the trial of the BKV associates is still under review.
The suspects and their lawyers attested the transfer of the trial from the capital city Budapest to the Kecskemét Tribunal.  This has been a controversial occurrence in the trial because Kecskemét is generally considered to be politically sympathetic to the prosecutors.
According to András Kádár, the lawyer of defendant number one Miklós Hagyó, the transfer has damaged the integrity of the case and abused the defendants’ rights.  Kádár also complained about the lack of transparency in the transfer process.
I’ve written other posts about the transfer to the Kecskemét Tribunal which can be readhere, here, and here.


Source: http://thehagyocase.wordpress.com/